About the project

Since Darwin’s times, evolutionary theory has been conceptualized as a causal theory. From the causalist perspective, a great number of versions have been postulated. One of them is the mechanistic approach, focused essentially on natural selection, developed among others in Barros (2008) and DesAutels (2016). In a similar manner, ecological theory studies how species are affected by biotic and abiotic factors, postulating different mechanisms that explain those interactions (Roughgarden 1998, Pásztor et al. 2016, Pâslaru 2018). For example, in modern coexistence theory, two mechanisms determine whether species can coexist or not. Also, the relationship between ecology and evolution (also called eco-evolutionary dynamics) can be represented as the interaction between different mechanisms at different levels of organization.

The main goal of the project is to analyze mechanistic approaches to causation and explore the feasibility of a mechanism-based framework for addressing causation in evolutionary biology (evolutionary and ecological theory) and related areas (biomedicine, etc.). This general aim is translated into three specific goals: 

  1. to offer an exhaustive analysis of the use of mechanism-based reasoning in evolutionary biology.
  2. to develop a framework that accounts for the role of mechanisms in evolutionary biology and related fields.
  3. to use the mechanism-based framework to address conceptual debates in the biomedical sciences.

 

Goal (1): The first goal of this project is to offer an exhaustive analysis of the use of mechanism-based reasoning in evolutionary biology. Mechanistic reasoning has been present in scientific reasoning for centuries, including biology (Nicholson 2012, Esposito and Baravalle 2023). Nevertheless, different explanatory and causal frameworks have been postulated by biologists and philosophers. It is necessary to clarify how pervasive is the mechanism-based reasoning in evolutionary biology in comparison with other possible approaches.  In addition, our aim is to analyze how this mechanism-based reasoning fits with the new mechanical philosophy and its depiction of what a mechanism is. It will be important to establish what an evolutionary mechanism is (Pérez-González and Luque 2019), what an ecological mechanism is (Heger 2022), and the possibility of unifying all of them under the same theoretical framework (Pásztor et al. 2016, Govaert 2018, Luque and Baravalle 2021).

Goal (2): The second goal of this project is to, based on the previous work, develop a mechanistic approach for evolutionary theory. Evolutionary biologists sometimes talk about evolutionary causes as mechanisms acting upon populationsFollowing this use, some philosophers have tried to develop a mechanistic approach for those causes. Until now, the mechanistic approach has mainly focused on natural selection (Barros, 2008; DesAutels, 2016; Illari and Williamson, 2010). Mechanists have been arguing about how that approach fits with natural selection, almost without devoting attention to the other evolutionary causes. However, the alternative approaches (e.g. the force interpretation, the counterfactual approach, etc.) tend to locate the different evolutionary causes in a single framework. This single framework aspiration results from the fact that biologists consider that all evolutionary causes are entities of the same kind (i.e. entities capable of producing changes in allele or trait frequencies, and mathematically tractable their (combined) effects). Furthermore, a common conceptual framework allows researchers to deal with those causes, their dynamics, and their relationships, in a more effective way. Given this situation, we consider that the mechanistic approach should take on the challenge of conceptualizing all evolutionary causes as mechanisms (DesAutels 2018), in order to be a legitimate conceptual framework on the same footing than the other approaches (Pérez-Gonzalez and Luque 2019). In fact, a general, all-encompassing perspective is already present in the new mechanistic philosophy itself (see Machamer, Darden, and Craver, 2000, p. 2; Illari and Williamson, 2012). This could be a promising strategy for addressing some traditional topics in philosophy of biology. It would also underline the link between evolutionary biology and other areas of science where the mechanistic framework is generally accepted, like molecular biology.

Goal (3): The third goal is to, following the mechanism-based framework previously developed, address conceptual debates about biomedical sciences. In the philosophy of biomedical sciences, mechanism-based approaches have been introduced to address important debates. Those approaches aim to address questions such as causal inference (Russo and Williamson 2007), explanation (Craver and Darden 2013) or even science communication (Pérez-González 2020). Nonetheless, current mechanism-based approaches have faced severe criticisms (Howick 2011; van Eersel et al. 2019). A mechanism-based approach that integrates our previous work on the nature and roles of evolutionary mechanisms may overcome previous criticisms and provide the basis for addressing ongoing debates.